Home Appraisals: What Happens if Yours is Low?
Home appraisals can make or break a real estate transaction – so what can you do if your appraisal comes back low? This guide explains.

Why is a Home Appraisal So Important?

When a borrower asks a lender for the money to buy a home, the lender sends out an appraiser. The appraiser is an independent third party who determines how much a home is worth. Using nearby, similar properties, the appraiser compares the subject home to figure out a home’s legitimate value – and the lender uses this information to decide whether it can give someone a mortgage on the property.
Lenders typically don’t like to give a borrower more money than a home is worth. That’s because, statistically, homeowners are more likely to default on their payments when they are paying toward a home that’s worth less than what they owe on it.
When an appraiser determines that a home’s value is equal to or greater than what the buyer is asking to borrow, the lender can feel comfortable making the loan. However, if the appraiser discovers that the home is worth less than what the seller is asking, the lender is unlikely to approve the loan. This is known as a low appraisal, and it can derail a real estate deal.
Related: The 7 most common showing mistakes sellers make

What Happens if Your Home Appraises Low?

If your appraisal comes back low, your buyer has a few options. They can ask you to lower your sales price, come up with additional money to make up for what their lender won’t allow them to borrow, or walk away from the deal. Often, prospective buyers ask sellers to accept less money for the home first.

Get a FREE CMA on your home in 24hrs or less!

It's a SELLERS Market! Even if you are even just THINKING about selling, knowing what your home's TRUE market value is valuable information. Fill in your info below and we will send you a complete Market Value Report that shows you what it is REALLY worth in today's market.
    Set an appointment with us and we will come to your home and do a walk-through which will allow us to give you an even more accurate market value.

What Options Do You Have After a Low Appraisal?

It’s up to you whether you choose to lower your sales price or otherwise make the deal more appealing to your buyers. You also have some other options:

  • You can ask your real estate agent to get in touch with the lender to find out whether the appraiser is willing to look at new information. Then, you and your real estate agent can work together to ensure that the appraiser has all the information they need to come up with an accurate value for your home. That may include receipts you have for recent home improvements, additional information and data on comparable properties, or other documentation that you believe will change the appraiser’s view.
  • You can ask your real estate agent to talk to the lender about requesting a second appraisal. A second appraisal involves a different appraiser who will look at the situation with a fresh eye. However, if you take this route, you need to know that you will most likely be responsible for paying the cost of the second appraisal, which usually runs between $300 and $500.

Related: 5 important safety-related tasks to take care of before buyers come to see your home

Are You Selling or Buying a Home in Aspen?

If you’re ready to sell your home in Aspen, Woody Creek, Basalt, Carbondale or Snowmass, we may be able to help you.
Get in touch with us right now to find out how much your home is worth – and discover how we’ll be able to help you sell it quickly and for top dollar.
If you’re also looking for a home for sale in Aspen or a nearby community, check out our listings by price: